Who hasn’t seen the oil covered seabirds and big-eyed otters in the news after massive oil spills like Exxon Valdez and Deepwater Horizon? The images represent how oil production can impact the marine environment and are visually powerful. Oil covered zooplankton may not be equally heartbreaking – but it should be. Exposure to toxic oil compounds during critical life phases of low trophic level copepods have the potential to shift entire ecosystem dynamics.

Copepod close up. Photo
Calanus finmarchicus – a small crustacean with great importance. The cylinder in the middle of the animal (the lipid sac) contains nutritious lipids that other species in the marine food web depend on. Photo: Elise Skottene

The marine ecosystem depends on zooplankton

The marine food web in the North Atlantic and Arctic Oceans depends on Calanus copepods, because they contain a lot of nutritious fat. A copepod is a type of marine zooplankton (“animal plankton”) drifting in the ocean. Copepods are distantly related to shrimp and crabs, and they belong to the group of animals called crustaceans. They accumulate a lot of fat (or lipids) in order to survive a period of inactivity or dormancy (called diapause), similar to a bear preparing for hibernation. They spend diapause at depth, slowly spending their lipid storage, and emerge in surface waters in time to feed on the spring phytoplankton (“plant plankton”) bloom1. Species like cod and herring time their reproduction cycles to the re-emergence of copepods, which are essential prey2.

Collecting copepods in diapause

Copepods spending the winter at 500 meters depth are not isolated from human-made disturbances. They may be exposed to toxic oil components from leakages from oil transportation pipes on the seabed, or from simply spending dormancy in the proximity of an oil platform that releases produced water at depth. In 2016, we performed an experiment where copepods in diapause from the Trondheimsfjord were exposed to toxic oil compounds (polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, PAHs) while they terminated diapause and developed into adults in laboratory conditions. Using RNA sequencing and bioinformatic software, we identified a large set of genes related to lipid metabolism in Calanus finmarchicus (norsk: raudåte) and evaluated their expression in response to oil exposure.

Three photos collecting copepods with a net from a boat. Photo
Christoffer Høyvik Hilde and Siv Anina Etter in the process of collecting copepods in diapause from the Trondheimsfjord, November 2016. Photo: Elise Skottene
Water soluble fraction samples in the lab. Photo
Generation of the exposure medium: a water-soluble fraction of crude oil components using methodology developed by SINTEF and NTNU (IBI’s now retired Anders J. Olsen).

Lipid metabolism and diapause

The lipids that are so essential as energy source for fish and other higher trophic level species, are also important for the copepods that need to survive months without feeding. Individual lipid content may also have a role as an internal cue for diapause entry, duration and termination. Specifically, the copepods may be triggered to terminate diapause when a lower threshold of lipids is reached during diapause3,4. This results in the copepods “waking up” and migrate to surface waters to molt into reproducing adults.

Oil exposure disrupts lipid metabolism in Calanus copepods

We observed that the copepods that were exposed to oil components during diapause termination spent their lipids in the lipid sac at a slower rate that un-exposed copepods. This reduced lipid catabolic rate was also reflected by the gene expression results: several genes involved in lipid catabolism – the process of breaking down lipid molecules – were downregulated in the oil-exposed copepods. This resulted in the oil-exposed copepods having more leftover lipids at the end of the experiment than the non-exposed group. In nature, copepods being exposed to petrogenic oil may thus reach the lipid threshold for diapause termination at a later point in time. Exposure to oil pollution during this critical life phase can result in a delayed emergence from diapause, which can impact the entire marine ecosystem.

Two illustrations showing copepods emerging from diapause
Copepods time the emergence from diapause with the spring phytoplankton (“plant plankton”) bloom, in order to molt into adults and reproduce while having access to food in surface waters (left). Copepods that are exposed to oil pollution during diapause termination (right) may become delayed in emerging from dormancy. This can result in the copepods missing the phytoplankton bloom, which can result in starvation and reduced ability to reproduce for the copepods. This can further have negative consequences for species depending on copepods as prey. Figure made by Elsevier Illustration Services for Elise Skottene

Severe potential ecological consequences

A delayed emergence to the surface can result in copepod populations missing the spring phytoplankton bloom, which is their primary source of food. Starvation during the reproductive period can limit the copepods’ ability to produce eggs5, and the survival of Calanus populations may be critically reduced if the timing is shifted drastically. Lower copepod availability in the surface waters at the time of hatching of cod larvae means less prey available and potentially lower survival of cod. In conclusion, ecosystem dynamics may be altered dramatically in a bottom-up effect in areas with chronic emissions of oil components.

These potential ecological consequences are of particular importance in high latitude areas with a short period of high biomass production. The Norwegian Government has opened for several new areas for oil exploration in the Barents and Norwegian Seas6. Further oil production will increase in the probability of accidental leakages and accidents, with increased risk to cause harm to an ecologically vulnerable Arctic area. Further studies are needed to reproduce our results, and to quantify the potential ecological consequences, in the Atlantic and the vulnerable Arctic marine ecosystems.

References

  1. Hirche, H.-J. Diapause in the Marine Copepod, Calanus Finmarchicus – A Review. Ophelia 1996, 44 (October), 129–143. https://doi.org/10.1080/00785326.1995.10429843.
  2. Beaugrand, G.; Brander, K. M.; Alistair Lindley, J.; Souissi, S.; Reid, P. C. Plankton Effect on Cod Recruitment in the North Sea. Nature 2003, 426 (6967), 661–664. https://doi.org/10.1038/nature02164.
  3. Johnson, C. L.; Leising, a W.; Runge, J. a; Head, E. J. H.; Pepin, P.; Plourde, S.; Durbin, E. G. Characteristics of Calanus Finmarchicus Dormancy Patterns in the Northwest Atlantic. ICES J. Mar. Sci. 2008, 65 (3), 339–350. https://doi.org/10.1093/icesjms/fsm171.
  4. Maps, F.; Plourde, S.; Zakardjian, B. Control of Dormancy by Lipid Metabolism in Calanus Finmarchicus: A Population Model Test. Mar. Ecol. Prog. Ser. 2010, 403, 165–180. https://doi.org/10.3354/meps08525.
  5. Hirche, H.-J.; Meyer, U.; Niehoff, B. Egg Production of Calanus Finmarchicus: Effect of Temperature, Food and Season. Mar. Biol. 1997, 127 (4), 609–620. https://doi.org/10.1007/s002270050051.
  6. Energidepartementet, O. Utlysning Av 25. Konsesjonsrunde. Pressemelding.

Further reading

Elise Skottene profile photo
Elise Skottene

Elise Skottene is a PhD candidate at the Department of Biology. She belongs to the research groups for marine sciences and environmental toxicology.